Han Fei

People follow their interest, not their goodness: a sound state rests on law, reward and punishment.

Political realism-280 · -233 ChinaHan (China)

Life

Han Fei (c. 280-233 BC) was a prince of the state of Han, a pupil of Xunzi, and the leading thinker of Chinese Legalism. He brought together his predecessors' ideas on law (fa), the technique of rule (shu) and authority (shi). For him people act from interest, not virtue, so a strong state rests on clear laws, rewards and punishments rather than on moral example. His writings, collected in the Han Feizi, impressed the future First Emperor of Qin; he died in prison in Qin in 233 BC.

Main works

240 BC
Han Feizi

A collection of chapters on law, the technique of rule and power, the foundation of Legalism (approximate date).

240 BC
Wudu (The Five Vermin), ch. 49

A critique of scholars, wandering knights and others who in his view undermine the law; times change, and so must remedies (approximate date).

240 BC
Beinei (Guarding Against the Inside), ch. 17

A ruler should trust neither his ministers, his wife nor his sons (approximate date).

In his own words

« Ancient and modern times have different customs, and the new and the old call for different measures. »

夫古今異俗,新故異備。

Han Feizi, ch. 49 (Wudu), § 5
« People by nature submit to power; few can be won over by righteousness. »

且民者固服於勢,寡能懷於義。

Han Feizi, ch. 49 (Wudu), § 6
« Weeping and not wanting to punish is benevolence; but that one cannot help punishing is the law. »

夫垂泣不欲刑者,仁也;然而不可不刑者,法也。

Han Feizi, ch. 49 (Wudu), § 5
« The ruler's trouble lies in trusting others. If he trusts others, he is controlled by others. »

人主之患在於信人。信人,則制於人。

Han Feizi, ch. 17 (Beinei), § 1

Positions

click a row to see the evidence
Where does knowledge come from?Source of knowledge
Empiricism (from experience)Rationalism (from reason)
Interpretation

Claims must be checked against observable results; he mocks those who rely on unverifiable authority.

Han Feizi (3rd c. BC), chap. "Xian xue" (Prominent Schools)

Are humans naturally good?Human nature
Fundamentally weak or corruptFundamentally good or perfectible
Interpretation

People act from self-interest, so order comes from clear laws, rewards and punishments, not from trusting goodness.

Han Feizi (3rd c. BC), chap. "Eight Villainies" and "Five Vermin"