PhilosophersThomas Nagel

Thomas Nagel

Consciousness is a subjective point of view that physics does not describe: our idea of nature must be widened.

Analytic philosophy1937 United StatesBelgrade (Yugoslavia)

Life

American philosopher born in 1937, professor at New York University. His 1974 article on the bat argues that consciousness is a subjective point of view that physics, as we conceive it, does not describe. He holds that our conception of nature must be widened to include the mind. He matters for the questions on the mind and consciousness.

Main works

1974
What Is It Like to Be a Bat?

Argues that consciousness has a subjective character irreducible to physical explanations.

1986
The View from Nowhere

Examines the tension between the subjective point of view and objectivity.

2012
Mind and Cosmos

Argues that materialist neo-Darwinism cannot account for consciousness.

In his own words

« Without consciousness the mind-body problem would be much less interesting. With consciousness it seems hopeless. »
What Is It Like to Be a Bat? (1974), repris dans Mortal Questions (1979), p. 166

Positions

click a row to see the evidence
Does God exist?God
AtheismTheism
Stated

He is an atheist and admits he hopes there is no God.

Nagel, The Last Word (1997)

Where does knowledge come from?Source of knowledge
Empiricism (from experience)Rationalism (from reason)
Interpretation

Reason has its own authority that cannot be explained away by experience or biology.

Nagel, The Last Word (1997)

Is the mind more than matter?Mind and body
MaterialismDualism
Stated

Consciousness cannot be reduced to physics, so materialism is incomplete; he rejects dualism and looks for a wider natural view.

Nagel, What Is It Like to Be a Bat? (1974) ; Mind and Cosmos (2012)

Do good and evil exist objectively?Status of morality
Anti-realism (morality is human-made)Moral realism (objective moral truths)
Stated

Values are real and can be recognized by reason, not just projections of our feelings.

Nagel, The View from Nowhere (1986)

Does life have a given meaning?Meaning of life
No given meaning (absurd, to be created)Objective meaning (nature, God, the Good)
Stated

Life has no given meaning and is absurd, but this need not be a reason for despair.

Nagel, The Absurd (1971)