PhilosophersPlutarque

Plutarque

Eating flesh deprives a living being of light and life for a little pleasure; what is astonishing is that anyone ever began.

Platonism46 · 120 GreeceChaeronea (Boeotia)

Life

Writer and priest of Apollo at Delphi (c. 46 - c. 120), born at Chaeronea in Boeotia. He wrote the Parallel Lives and a vast collection of essays, the Moralia, including the discourse On the Eating of Flesh, which wonders how anyone ever began to eat the flesh of animals.

Main works

100
Parallel Lives

Biographies of famous Greeks and Romans, paired and compared.

100
Moralia

A collection of essays on ethics, religion and daily life.

100
On the Eating of Flesh (De esu carnium)

Two discourses against eating animal flesh.

In his own words

« Why do you falsely accuse the earth of being unable to feed you? »

Τί καταψεύδεσθε τῆς γῆς ὡς τρέφειν μὴ δυναμένης;

De esu carnium I, 994a
« I wonder with what feeling, in what state of mind, the first man touched slaughter with his mouth and brought to his lips the flesh of a dead animal. »

ὁ πρῶτος ἄνθρωπος ἥψατο φόνου στόματι καὶ τεθνηκότος ζῴου χείλεσι προσήψατο σαρκὸς

De esu carnium I, 993b

Positions

click a row to see the evidence
Does God exist?God
AtheismTheism
Interpretation

A Platonist priest at Delphi, he believes in a supreme good god and in providence, while the divine remains beyond full understanding.

Plutarque, Sur Isis et Osiris ; Sur les délais de la justice divine (Moralia, v. 100)

What makes an action good?Basis of morality
Duty (deontology)Consequences (consequentialism)Character (virtue ethics)Other (divine law, relationships, value creation…)

His Lives judge people by their character and virtues, and the Moralia teach moral progress by habit.

Plutarque, Vies parallèles ; Comment progresser dans la vertu (Moralia, v. 100)