PhilosophersJ. J. C. Smart

J. J. C. Smart

Sensations are brain processes: nothing in the world escapes physics.

Analytic philosophy1920 · 2012 AustraliaCambridge (England)

Life

J. J. C. Smart (1920-2012), an Australian-British philosopher, taught mainly at Adelaide and then at the Australian National University (Canberra). He is one of the founders of the mind-brain identity theory: sensations are brain processes. He also defended act utilitarianism and wrote on time, science and the existence of God.

Main works

1959
Sensations and Brain Processes

Founding article of the mind-brain identity theory.

1963
Philosophy and Scientific Realism

Argues that science describes the world as it is.

1973
Utilitarianism: For and Against

A debate with Bernard Williams; Smart defends act utilitarianism.

In his own words

« That anything should exist at all does seem to me a matter for the deepest awe. »
« The Existence of God », Church Quarterly Review 156 (1955), p. 194

Positions

click a row to see the evidence
Does God exist?God
AtheismTheism
Stated

He argues that the existence of God is not credible given the evidence and the problem of evil.

Haldane & Smart, Atheism and Theism (1996)

Is the mind more than matter?Mind and body
MaterialismDualism
Stated

Sensations are identical with brain processes; reports of experience can be given in topic-neutral terms that leave no extra non-physical thing.

Smart, 'Sensations and Brain Processes' (1959)

Are we truly free?Freedom
Determinism (no free will)Free will
Stated

Freedom and determinism are compatible: acting freely means acting from one's own desires, not being uncaused.

Smart, 'Free-Will, Praise and Blame' (1961)

What makes an action good?Basis of morality
Duty (deontology)Consequences (consequentialism)Character (virtue ethics)Other (divine law, relationships, value creation…)

He defends act utilitarianism: the right action is the one with the best consequences for general happiness.

Smart & Williams, Utilitarianism: For and Against (1973)

Do good and evil exist objectively?Status of morality
Anti-realism (morality is human-made)Moral realism (objective moral truths)
Interpretation

He sees moral judgements as expressing attitudes rather than describing objective facts.

Smart, Ethics, Persuasion and Truth (1984)